IJLR
INDIAN JOURNAL OF LEGAL REVIEW
ISSN: 2583-2344 • Volume 6 and Issue 12 of 2026
πŸ“š View Issue πŸ” Track / Certificates
Coercive Control in India: Assessing the Need for a Separate Criminal Offence
Version v1 Open Access Journal Article

Coercive Control in India: Assessing the Need for a Separate Criminal Offence

Authors – YASHASHVI MALIK* & DR. MAYA DEVI**
* STUDENT AT CHANDIGARH UNIVERSITY
** STUDENT AT CHANDIGARH UNIVERSITY
BEST CITATION – YASHASHVI MALIK & DR. MAYA DEVI, COERCIVE CONTROL IN INDIA: ASSESSING THE NEED FOR A SEPARATE CRIMINAL OFFENCE, INDIAN JOURNAL OF LEGAL REVIEW (IJLR), 6 (12) OF 2026, PG. 76–89, APIS – 3920-0001, ISSN – 2583-2344, AIT – IJLR/MBDO-0016.
ABSTRACT

Coercive control raises a difficult question for Indian criminal law: when does a continuing restriction of a partner’s freedom become a wrong that existing offences do not adequately describe? The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 already recognises emotional and economic abuse, while sections 85 and 86 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 punish cruelty within specified relationships and thresholds. This paper examines the relationship between these protections through doctrinal and comparative legal research. It develops an analytical test based on the course of conduct, coercive means, restriction of practical choice, mental element and relationship coverage. Applying this test reveals substantial existing protection, alongside a possible mismatch between the cumulative wrong of domination and the requirements of criminal cruelty. England and Wales and Scotland provide contrasting ways of defining the wrong, but their experience also exposes difficulties of proof and implementation. The paper argues for a narrowly defined offence only where its additional contribution can be demonstrated. It proposes a requirement of serious restriction of practical freedom, a subjective mental element, coverage of current and former intimate relationships, and ordinary prosecution burdens. Criminal accountability must operate alongside accessible protection, residence and financial remedies. The contribution is a conditional framework for reform; it does not predict that criminalisation alone would improve women’s safety.

πŸ“„ IJLRV6I127F.pdf (Full Journal Cover + Article) Open Fullscreen ↗